Why are sugars added to foods? Beyond flavor and sweetness:

Preservation: In jams and jellies, sugar absorbs moisture, reducing available water and thereby reducing bacterial growth potential.

Fermentation: sugar is the fuel for yeast in fermented foods. The gas produced from yeast fermentation makes bread rise.

Browning (caramelization and Maillard reaction): When sugar is exposed to heat, the browning reaction adds flavor and colour to bread crusts and cookies.

Tenderization: Sugar is used to keep baked goods moist and can delay staleness. (softens gluten networks)

Crystallization control: leading to the creation of taffy vs hard candy

Boiling point increase: Sugar increases the boiling point of solutions

Freezing point depression: sugar reduces the freezing point and provides scoopabiity to frozen desserts such as ice cream.

Texture: Sugar provides viscosity or syrupy textures in sauces

Sugar provides bulk which impacts mouthfeel and texture (smoothness of ice cream)

Sugar stabilizes egg whites when whipped together to keep angel food cake light and fluffy.

Flavour: Sugar enhances flavor, releases aromas, and balances the bitterness of cocoa, the sourness of yogurt and the acidity of tomatoes.

What happens when foods are made without sugar?

Due to the many functions of sugar in food, the reduction or removal of sugar is not as simple as replacing it with another ingredient or cutting it out. The goal of reformulation would be to improve the nutritional profile of the food, however, when replacing sugar, it often requires more than one ingredient, some of which are additives. In other cases, sugars are removed but starches are added, and the resulting glycemic index may be higher, and the product may have the same calories as before.

In the case of ice cream, sugar provides sweetness, creamy texture, bulk and a depression of the freezing point to make it scoopable. When sugar is removed from ice cream, often artificial sweeteners are used for sweetness, but they don’t help with the freezing point so then glycerol needs to be added. Or sugar alcohols are used but they don’t add bulk so then maltodextrins are added. In the end the calorie content often comes out the same, the GI increases and the ingredient list grows.

Bottom Line:

In most foods, sugar contributes many functional properties beyond sweetness. Replacement of sugar, one-to-one with another ingredient is not possible. Ideally the replacement of sugar should have the goal of improved nutritional profile and deliver a product of lower calorie, GI and clean ingredient list. If it can’t do that, the better option is to eat smaller portions of the sugar containing food and to remember the 80-20 Rule. Aim to eat 80% healthy foods and 20% not so healthy foods.